BaseballGuru.com Home Page

Baseball Analysis  Bill Burgess / Research & Analysis

[From Bill Burgess' Ty Cobb Memorial Collection]

ALL-TIME ALL-STAR TEAMS OF PROMINENT BASEBALL FIGURES

By Bill Burgess III

Scroll to the RIGHT to see teams! --->

Name Credentials Date Named Died 1Base 2nd Base 3rd Base Shortstop Outfield Outfield Outfield Catcher Pitcher Pitcher Pitcher Pitcher Pitcher Pitcher Pitcher Pitcher Manager
Billy Sunday NL OF(1883-90) Chi. D. Trib. pp. B1, Jan. 24, 1909 Nov., '35 Anson McPhee Denny Wagner Delehanty Lange Cobb Ewing / Kling / Kelly / Bresnahan Clarkson Mathewson Galvin Walsh Breitenstein Brown
Tim Murnane     ML 1B(1872-78), Bost.spwr,(1888-1917,Feb) 1914 Feb, '17 Anson N.Williams R. Barnes B. Caruthers Lange J. Jackson Cobb C. Bennett
Ring Lardner               Spwr. (Chi,1907-19),  (NYC,1919-20's) late, 1915 Sept., '33 Daubert Collins Baker Maranville J. Jackson Speaker Cobb Schalk / Archer Johnson Alexander Mathewson Cicotte Rucker Willis Mitchell
Cap Anson ML 1B(1871-97), ML man(1875,79-98 Sporting News, pp. 8, Jan. 17, 1818 Apr., '22 Anson Pfeffer Williamson Barnes Bill Lange Gore Ryan / Duffy Ewing / Kelly Rusie Clarkson McCormick
Jack Dunn Owned Baltimore Orioles minor L. team Wash.Post, pp. 18, 2-24-1918 Oct., '28 Sisler Collins Collins Wagner Delehanty Speaker Cobb Ewing / Wilbert Robinson Johnson Mathewson Ruth Rusie Waddell
Sam Crane    ML 2B(1880-90),  NYC spwr. (1890-1925) pp. 476, col. 2, BBM, Apr. 1918 June, '25 Chase Lajoie Collins Wagner McAleer Speaker Cobb Ewing Mathewson Rusie Johnson McGraw
Billy Murray Pirates man. '07-09, Cards coach, '13  pp. 8, Sporting News, Feb. 9, 1922  Mar., '37 Sisler Lajoie Collins Wagner Fred Clarke Speaker Cobb Ewing Johnson
Wilbert Robinson ML pl(1890-02), Bro man('14-31) 1922 Aug., '34 Sisler Collins Frisch Wagner / Hornsby Keeler Speaker Cobb O'Neil / Kling Mathewson Johnson Waddell McGinnity Rommel Walsh
William B. Hanna NYC sp.wr. (1884-30) pp. 300, BBM, June, 1924 Nov., '30 Chase Collins Collins Wagner Ruth Keeler Cobb Ewing / Bresnahan Radbourne Mathewson Johnson Pennock
Hughie Jennings,  A Team NL SS, 1891-02; Det. M. '07-20; Giants c24-25 pp. A4, LA Times, Jan. 10, 1926 Feb., '28 Chase Lajoie Collins Wagner Cobb Keeler Speaker Bresnahan / Ewing  Mathewson Johnson Rusie Waddell
Hughie Jennings, B Team NL SS, 1891-02; Det. M. '07-20; Giants c24-25 pp. A4, LA Times, Jan.10 , 1926 Feb., '28 Sisler Collins McGraw Wallace Kelley Youngs Ruth  Kling / W. Robinson Alexander Walsh M. Brown McGinnity
Hughie Jennings, C Team NL SS, 1891-02; Det. M. '07-20; Giants c24-25 pp. A4, LA Times, Jan.10 , 1926 Feb., '28 Anson Hornsby Weaver Frisch Burkett Lange Hamilton Carrigan / Schalk Young Donovan Shocker Plank
John B. Sheridan St. Louis sp. wr.(1887-29) Sporting News, Mar. 4, 1926 Apr., '30 Chase Hornsby Collins Wagner Keeler Speaker Cobb Bresnahan / Ewing / Kling Mathewson Alexander Johnson Young Nichols Breitenstein Plank M. Brown
Miller Huggins NL 2B, '04-16, Cards man., '13-17, Yank,man, '18-29 pp. 20, Wash. Post, 2-05-29 Sept., '29 Chase Collins Collins Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Bresnahan / Kling Johnson Waddell Pennock Mathewson Alexander
Ban Johnson       AL only Cinc. spwr.(1887-93)AL Pres.('01-27) pp. 5, Sporting News,  Mar.14, 1929 Mar., '31 Sisler Collins Collins Wallace Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane / Criger Young Johnson Plank Bender
Irwin M. Howe Chicago Daily Trib., April, 1930 Mar., '30 Anson Collins Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Schalk Johnson Young
Robert W. Beall        AL BBM, pp. 374, July, 1930 ? Chase Lajoie Collins Wallace Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane / Schalk Johnson Walsh Waddell Bender Young
Robert W. Beall        NL BBM, pp. 374, July, 1930 ? Tenney Hornsby Steinfeldt Wagner Delehanty Donlin Keeler Bresnahan / Kling Mathewson Alexander Reulbach Brown McGinnity
John McGraw            NL pl. (1891-06), NLman('02-32) pp. 7, column 6, Sporting News,  Nov. 20, 1930 Feb., '34 Gehrig Hornsby Collins Wagner Ruth Keeler Cobb Ewing / Bresnahan Mathewson Johnson J. McMahon J. Clarkson Rusie Walsh Joss Waddell
John K. Tener NL Pres.,   1914-18 pp. 3, col. 4, Sporting News,  Feb. 12, 1931 1946 Chase Lajoie Collins Wagner Clarke Ruth Cobb Ewing / Mike Kelly Radbourne Mathewson Johnson Alexander
Babe Ruth          AL ('14-34),  NL('35), NL coach ('38) pp. S1, NY Times, Jan. 25, 1931 1948 Chase Lajoie Collins Wagner Jackson Cobb Hooper Schalk Mathewson Pennock Plank Alexander Johnson
Walter Johnson AL ('07-27),  AL Man('29-35) Bill James' Hist. BB Abstract, pp.157, 1934 1948 Chase Lajoie / Collins Collins Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Dickey / Kling Alexander Mathewson Waddell Vance
Jimmy Archer NL Catcher, 1909-18 Sporting News, April, 1935 1958 Chase Evers Collins Wagner Fred Clarke Bill Lange Cobb Kling / Criger Mathewson Brown Joss Young Waddell
William J. Dwyer spwr. Wash.Post, pp. FS4, 4-28-1935 Chase Fred Dunlap J. Denny/ J.Collen Wagner Ruth Mike Kelly Cobb Ewing / Tom Daly Johnson
Hugh Fullerton      NYC sp.wr. (1893-30's) Sporting News, Jan.23, pp.3, 1936 1945 Chase Lajoie Collins Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane / Kling Mathewson Johnson Young Alexander Waddell
Roger Bresnahan NL pl. & man. ('03-15),  AL1900 pp. A10, LA Times, My. 26, 1936 1944 Chance Gehringer Collins Wagner Fred Clarke Beaumont Keeler Marty Bergen Mathewson Waddell Johnson
Hugh Duffy NL pl (1888-00, 04-06), AL 1901 Feb,1936 1954 Tenney Lajoie Collins Wagner T. McCarthy Hamilton J. Kelly King Kelly / Bergen Nichols Rusie Willis
Joe McCarthy NL man. ('26-30),AL man. ('31-46, 48-50) pp. 4, col. 6, Sporting News, Jul. 23, 1936 1978 Gehrig Collins Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Hartnett / Cochrane Johnson Mathewson Walsh Grove
Edson E. Brewster Baseball telegrapher (1890-1938) pp. 4, col. 6, Sporting News, Jun. 30, 1938 1954 Tenney Lajoie Collins Wagner Ruth J. Jackson Cobb Bresnahan Johnson Mathewson Bender Rusie Young Pennock Ruth Grove Hanlon, McGraw, Huggins
Fred Logan        clubhouse man(Giants,'89-38)(Yanks,'03-38) pp. 4, col. 6, Sporting News, Aug 25, 1938 1947 Chase / Gehrig Lajoie Collins Wagner H. Duffy Speaker Cobb Ewing / Dickey Mathewson Young Johnson Pennock McGraw
John B. Foster    A team Cle. & NYC sp.wr.(1896-41) Spalding Guide, Feb., 1938 1941 Gehrig Lajoie Collins Wagner Ruth,10 Speaker Cobb Ewing Young
John B. Foster    B team Spalding Guide editor, 1908-41 Spalding Guide, Feb., 1938 1941 Fred Tenney Collins Art Devlin Herman Long Fred Clarke H. Earl Averill Keeler Bresnahan / Hartnett Mathewson
Dick Kinsella Giants' scout, 1907-32 pp. 81, NY Times, Feb. 26, 1939 1939 Terry / Chance Lajoie ? Doyle / Frisch Collins / Traynor Wagner / Cronin / Tinker Keeler / F. Clarke Speaker Cobb Bresnahan / Kling / Dickey Mathewson McGinnity Johnson Hubbell Grove
Amos Rusie NL pitcher (1889-95, 97-98) pp. 5, col. 2, Sporting News,  Dec. 28, 1939 1942 Brouthers Lajoie Collins Long / Wagner Lange Delehanty Keeler Ewing Clarkson Nichols Radbourne Young
Mickey Welch NL pitcher, 1880-91 1939 1941 Doyle Frisch McGraw E. Williamson Duffy Keeler Cobb Ewing / Kling / Kelly Mathewson Keefe Clarkson Hubbell
Bill Klem NL umpire, 1905-1941 1939 1951 Chase Collins / Frisch Collins Wagner / Steinfedt Ruth Beaumont Cobb Bresnahan / Hartnett / Kling Mathewson Johnson M. Brown Alexander Hubbell
Frankie Frisch NL 2B / 3B, 1919-37;  NL M, '33-38,40-46,50-51,NL c'49 Chi. Daily N.  pp. 21, Jul. 10, 1940 1973 Chase / Sisler Frisch Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Hartnett
Bill McKechnie ML IF, '10-18,20;ML man 15, 22-46, AL c,'47-49,52-53 Chi. Daily N.  pp. 21, Jul. 10, 1940 1965 Chase / Sisler Frisch Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Hartnett
Pie Traynor Pir. 3B, '20-37; Pir. Man., '34-39; Chi. Daily N.  pp. 21, Jul. 10, 1940 1972 Chase / Sisler Frisch Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Hartnett
Hank Gowdy NL C / 1B,  1910-30;   NL coach, '29-48 Chi. Daily N.  pp. 21, Jul. 10, 1940 1966 Chase / Sisler Frisch Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Hartnett
Charlie "Jolly Cholly" Grimm NL 1B, 1916, '18-36; NL M, 32-38,44-49, 52-56,60 Chi. Daily N.  pp. 21, Jul. 10, 1940 1983 Chase / Sisler Frisch Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Hartnett
Jimmy Burke       NL pl '98-99,02-05, AL '01, 14-23, 31-33 pp. 5, col. 2, Sporting News, Dec. 26, 1940 1942 Sisler Lajoie Collins / Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker / Cobb / Felsch Schulte/ Crawford Bresnahan Waddell Mathewson Alexander Chesbro
Jimmy Isaminger  Phil. sp.wr.(1905-1940,Sept.17) pp. 9, col. 6, Sporting News, My. 22, 1941 1946 Sisler Collins Collins Wagner Ruth Delahanty Cobb Cochrane / Killefer Young Plank Johnson Alexander
Bill Coughlin AL 3B 1901-08 pp. 5, col. 5, Sporting News, Jun.19, 1941 1943 Chase Lajoie Collins Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Dickey / Bresnahan Johnson Bill Donovan Waddell Grove Mack
Zack Wheat NL   1909-1926,  AL 1927 pp. 5, col. 7, Sporting News, Nov. 20, 1941 1972 Chase Hornsby Traynor Wagner J. Jackson Speaker Cobb Cochrane Mathewson Alexander Waddell Rucker
Hal Chase AL 1B (1905-14), FL('15), NL ('16-19) pp. 5, col. 2, Sporting News, Sept. 25, 1941 1947 Sisler Collins Hornsby Wagner Keeler Speaker DiMaggio Kling Mathewson Johnson Waddell Plank Vean Gregg
Gus Bache Yank/Giants Press Box warden('04-41) pp. 4, Sporting News, Oct. 2, 1942 SA '57 McInnis Lajoie Traynor Wagner Ruth DiMaggio Cobb Kling M. Brown Mathewson Hubbell
Waite Hoyt AL pitcher 1919-31,  NL 1931-38 pp. 12, col. 3, Sporting News, Apr. 2, 1942 1984 Gehrig Collins Traynor / Weaver / Dugan Everett Scott Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane / Hartnett / Dickey Johnson Hubbell Pennock Grove
Joe Dugan AL 3B (1917-28,31),   NL 1929 pp. 4, col. 5, Sporting News, Jan, 22, 1942 1982 Gehrig Gehringer Weaver Wagner Ruth DiMaggio Cobb Cochrane / Dickey Johnson Alexander
Henry P. Edwards,   AL only Cle sp.wr(1898-1928), AL office('28-42) pp. 10, col. 6, Sporting News, Jan, 29, 1942 1948 Gehrig / Sisler Lajoie / Collins / Gehringer Collins / Bradley / Dugan Cronin / Peckinpaugh / Boudreau Ruth / Simmons Speaker / DiMaggio Cobb / Keeler Cochrane / Schalk / O'Neil / Dickey Johnson Young Feller Grove Waddell Walsh
Nick Altrock AL pitcher('02-12), Sen. coach('12-53) pp. 5, col. 4, Sporting News, Nov. 26, 1942 1965 Chase Lajoie Collins Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Ewing Johnson Young Waddell Plank Coombs Bender Alexander Mathewson
Dolly Stark                   NL umpire (1928-35, 37-40, 42) BBM, June, 1942 1968 Gehrig Collins Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane / Kling / Hartnett Mathewson Johnson Alexander Grove Hubbell Pennock
Del Baker AL catcher (1914-16), AL '36-48, '53-60 BBM   Aug., 1942 1973 Gehrig Joe Gordon Rolfe Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane Johnson Mathewson Grove Feller
Muddy Ruel Al catcher ('15,17-34), AL'35-50, exc. '46 BBM    July, 1942 1963 Sisler Collins Dykes Peckinpaugh Ruth J. Jackson Cobb Cochrane / Schalk Johnson Grove
Ed Rumill Christian Science Monitor Spwr. (1929-72) Sporting News, Dec. 10, 1942 1987 Gehrig Collins Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Dickey Johnson
Grantland Rice  A team Spwr.  Atlanta ('02-05),   Cle. ('05-07) pp. 176, History of Baseball, 1943 1954 Sisler Collins Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Dickey Mathewson Alexander Johnson Young
Grantland Rice  B team Spwr.  Nashville ('07-10),  NYC ('10-54) History of Baseball, 1943 1954 Gehrig Lajoie Collins Bancroft J. Jackson DiMaggio T. Williams Cochrane / Hartnett Dean Grove Feller Waddell
Jimmy Collins NL 3B (1895-00),   AL 3B (1901-08) pp. 5, col. 5, Sporting News,  Mar. 11, 1 943 1943 Chase Lajoie          ---- Wagner Keeler H. Duffy Crawford Criger / Billy Sullivan Rusie Johnson Bill Dinneen Young Joss Walsh Chesbro
Cy Young                NL pitcher (1890-00,11), AL pitcher ('00-11) Oct, 1943 1955 Anson Lajoie Collins Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Bresnahan Johnson Waddell Alexander Walsh Young
Tris Speaker          AL OF (1907-28) pp. 7, col. 3, Sporting News,  Jan. 6, 1944 1958 Chase Collins Collins Wagner Ruth J. Jackson Cobb Cochrane Johnson
Tom Yawkey          Red Sox owner (Feb.,'33-76) pp. 3, col. 5, Sporting News, Mar. 29, 1945 1976 Gehrig Collins Weaver Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane / Dickey Johnson Grove
Duffy Lewis             AL OF (1910-20,     except 1918) BBM,  May, 1945 1979 Gehrig / Sisler Collins / Lajoie Traynor Wagner J. Jackson Speaker Cobb Dickey / Schalk Johnson Mathewson Walsh
Ernest Lanigan Sp. wr.,1887-91,07-11,16, H of F,'46-59 pp. 6, col. 3, Sporting News, Apr. 18, 1946 1962 Anson Lajoie Collins Wagner Keeler Speaker / Ruth Cobb Ewing / Kelly / Kling Young Walsh M. Brown Mathewson Johnson Waddell McCarthy
Warren Brown Spwr.   SF,  1916-22,       Chicago,  1923-74 Autobiography, Win, Lose, or Draw, 1947 1978 Chase / Grimm Hornsby / Frisch Weaver Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Schalk / Cochrane / Hartnett Waddell Alexander Gomez Dean Altrock Walsh Ruether Lingle Mungo McCarthy
Joe Cronin AL SS 1928-41,  IF 42-45;    NL IF '26-27 Sporting News, pp. 8, Feb.18, 1948 1984 Gehrig Gehringer Traynor Crosetti Ruth Combs Simmons Cochrane / Dickey Grove Feller
Joe Jackson,     AL only AL OF 1910-20 1948 1951 Chase Collins Weaver Wagner Jackson Speaker Cobb Steve O'Neil / Severeid Johnson Wood Coombs Plank Vean Gregg Walsh Mack
Honus Wagner  NL only NL pl. 1897-1917,  Pitts. coach '33-51 pp. 7,  Sporting News, Mar. 2, 1949 1955 Terry Lajoie / Hornsby Traynor Tinker Clarke Beaumont Keeler Bresnahan / Kling Mathewson Alexander Young
Steve O'Neal     AL only AL pl11-28;(35-51,exc.38-39,42),NL Man(52-54) BBM    Oct., 1950 1962 Gehrig Collins / Gehringer Weaver Cronin Ruth J.Jackson Cobb Cochrane / Dickey Johnson Grove
Connie Mack          NL catcher(1886-96), AL man(1901-50) autobiography, 1950 1955 Gehrig Collins Collins Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane / Dickey / Ewing Mathewson Johnson Young Grove Alexander Hubbell Waddell McGraw
Harry Salsinger         Detroit sp.wr. & ed. (1907-'58,Jan.) sports, pp. 63, Detroit News, My. 17, 1950 1958 Sisler Lajoie Collins Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane / Dickey Johnson Plank Waddell Walsh Pennock Grove Feller Mathewson / Alexander
Billy Southwood      NL (1913,15,18-27,29,33,40-51) 1950 1969 Gehrig Hornsby Traynor Wagner Ruth DiMaggio Cobb Dickey Alexander Young
John Kieran             NYC spwr. (1922-41) 1950 1981 Gehrig Collins Traynor Wagner Ruth DiMaggio Cobb Cochrane Mathewson
Ralph Kiner          NL OF (1946-54),  AL OF 1955 1950 SA Gehrig Hornsby Traynor Wagner Ruth DiMaggio Cobb Dickey Mathewson
Max  Carey             NL OF (1910-29) 1950 1976 Sisler Hornsby Traynor Wagner Ruth DiMaggio Cobb Dickey Johnson
Eddie Collins   A team     AL (1906-32),  Red Sox exec.(1933-51) 1950 1951 Sisler Gehringer Weaver Wagner J. Jackson Speaker Cobb Cochrane Grove Walsh Waddell Mack
Eddie Collins   B team   AL (1906-32),  Red Sox exec.(1933-51) 1950 1951 Gehrig Lajoie Traynor Cronin Ruth DiMaggio Simmons Dickey Johnson Alexander Mathewson McGraw
Eddie Collins,  C team   AL (1906-32),  Red Sox exec.(1933-51) 1950 1951 Chase Hornsby Collins Appling Musial Keeler Ott Bresnahan / Hartnett Hubbell Dean C. Young Pennock
Ed Barrow,          Yankees' GM, 1921-45 Detroit Man.('03-04), Red Sox Man.('18-20) autobiography, 1951 1953 Gehrig Lajoie Collins Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Bresnahan Young Waddell Mathewson Alexander McGinnity Johnson, Feb.23,39,pp.8 McCarthy
Walter Briggs           Detroit owner (1935-52) pp. 13, col. 1, Sporting News, Jan.23, 1952 1952 Chase Lajoie / Gehringer Collins Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane Johnson Mathewson
Ford Frick          NY spwr.21-35,   BB exec.35-65 pp. 3, Sporting News, Feb.13, 1952 1978 Terry,Gehrig,Sisler Frisch,Hornsby, Collins Traynor Durocher,Marion,Bancroft,Wright Ruth DiMaggio,Musial,Youngs Cobb Hartnett / Cochrane / Dickey Alexander Grove Hubbell Dean Pennock
Clark Griffith        Power team NL (1893-00,09-11), AL ('01-08,12-20) pp. 12 Sporting News, Jul.23, 1952 1952 Gehrig Lajoie Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Dickey / Cochrane Johnson Mathewson Alexander Grove Rusie Young
Clark Griffith       Scientific team    NL (1893-00,09-11), AL ('01-08,12-20) pp. 12 Sporting News, Jul.23, 1952 1952 Chase Collins Kell Rizzuto Jackson Lange Keeler Ewing Young Chesbro Joss Walsh Brown
Arlie Latham,1900's team AA '83-88, NL '90-96;  Giants coach,('09-11) pp. 13, col. 4, Sporting News, Dec.10, 1952 1952 Terry Gehringer / Lajoie Traynor Wagner Ruth DiMaggio Cobb Ewing / Dickey Mathewson Johnson Alexander Hubbell Waddell Young McGraw
Arlie Latham,1800's team Yanks pressbox,'36-52; Polo grnds,('32-52) pp. 13, col. 4, Sporting News, Dec.10, 1952 1952 Anson Pfeffer Denny Ward Jim Ryan Dan Brouthers Pete Browing King Kelly Radbourne Young Clarkson Comiskey
Dan Daniel NYC sp. wr. 1910- mid- 60's pp. 14, col. 1, Sporting News, Feb. 4,1953 1981 Gehrig Hornsby Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Dickey Mathewson Johnson
George Sisler          AL 1B (1915-28),  NL (1928-30) pp. 14, col. 3, Sporting News, Mar. 4, 1953 1973 Gehrig Hornsby / Collins Weaver Wagner,  1954 book Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane / Dickey Johnson Vance Alexander Grove Griffith
Bill McGowan AL umpire, (1925-54) pp. 14, col. 3, Sporting News, Jan.13, 1 954 1954 Gehrig Gehringer Ken Keltner Rizzuto Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane / Dickey Johnson Grove
Bobby Wallace NLSS,3B(1894-01,17-18), AL (1902-16) pp. 16, col. 5, Sporting News, Apr., 1954 1960 Chase Lajoie Collins / Bradley Wagner Delahanty / Crawford Speaker Cobb Criger / Bresnahan Johnson Joss Dinneen Young Rusie Bender
Frank Baker   (played against) AL 3B (1908-22, exc. 15,20) pp. 18, col. 5, Sporting News, Feb.16, 1955 1973 Sisler Collins Dykes Wallace Ruth Speaker Cobb Schang Johnson Grove Mack
Frank Baker   (combined) AL 3B (1908-22, exc. 15,20) pp. 18, col. 5, Sporting News, Feb.16, 1955 1973 Sisler Collins Rosen Rizzuto Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane Johnson Grove Mack
Ed Burkholder BB book author,   BB Immortals, '55 Book, Baseball Immortals,  1955 1978 Sisler Collins Collins Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Dickey / Cochrane Johnson Mathewson Alexander Young Grove Plank Mack
Sam Crawford NL OF (1899-1902),  AL (1903-17) 1955 1968 Chase Lajoie Bill Bradley Wagner J. Jackson Speaker Cobb Schalk Johnson Plank
Nap Lajoie            overall NL 2B (1896-00),  AL (1901-16) Feb.,1956 1959 Chase Hornsby Bill Bradley Wagner Beaumont McAleer Cobb Cochrane Mathewson Johnson Mack
Nap Lajoie            (his peers) NL 2B (1896-00),  AL (1901-16) pp. 14, col. 4, Sporting News, Aug. 23, 1950 1959 Chase Collins Bill Bradley Wagner Ruth Delahanty Cobb Bergen / Archer Ruse Joss Johnson Walsh Young
Jimmie Foxx,    1920's-1930's AL 1B (1925-42, 44-45) pp. 23, col. 2, Sporting News, March, 14, 1956 1967 Foxx Frisch Traynor Cronin Ruth DiMaggio Simmons Cochrane Grove
Jimmie Foxx,    1950's team AL 1B (1925-42, 44-45) pp. 23, col. 2, Sporting News, March, 14, 1956 1967 Kluszewski Schoendienst Kell Reese Williams Mays Musial Berra Roberts
Ed Walsh AL pitcher '04-16,  AL'23-30, exc '26-27 pp. 14, col. 4, Sporting News, Jan.16, 1957 1959 Gehrig Lajoie Collins Wagner Ruth J.Jackson Cobb Dickey Johnson Waddell Young McGraw
Joe King NY sports writer, 1930-68 pp. 4, col. 2, Sporting News, Jul. 9, 1958  1979 Gehrig Hornsby Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Dickey Johnson Mathewson Grove Hubbell  
Fred Clarke NL OF 1894-15, NL coach '25 1960 1960 Chase Collins Collins Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Kling Mathewson Waddell
Casey Stengel     NL team NLpl('12-25),NL(32-43,62-65,), AL (49-60) autobiography, 1961 1975 Terry  / Mize Hornsby / J.Robinson / Frisch Traynor Wagner / Banks Musial / Wheat Mays / Roush / Snider Waner Hartnett / Campy / Lombardi Alexander Mathewson Hubbell Dean Spahn Reulbach Vance
Casey Stengel     AL team NLpl('12-25),NL(32-43,62-65,), AL (49-60) autobiography, 1961 1975 Gehrig / Sisler Collins / Gehringer / Lajoie Weaver Cronin / Appling / Rizzuto Williams Speaker / Cobb / DiMaggio Ruth  / Jackson Cochrane / Dickey / Berra Johnson Feller Grove Walsh A. Reynolds V. Raschi Bender
Lee Allen Cinc. spwr('45-58),Hall of Fame, Historian.('59-69) 1969 Gehrig Hornsby Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb                         - Mack
Ty Cobb            AL OF,  1905-1928        Detroit man. 1921-26 autobiography, 1961 1961 Sisler  Collins Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker J. Jackson Cochrane / Dickey / Schalk Johnson Mathewson Ed Walsh Alexander Plank Grove Mack
Dazzy Vance NL pitcher (1922-35) 1961 1961 Sisler Hornsby Traynor Wagner Ruth DiMaggio Cobb Dickey Johnson Grove
Mickey Cochrane AL catcher '25-38, AL '50, AL VP '61-62 1961 1962 Sisler Collins Traynor Cronin Ruth Speaker Cobb Dickey / Hartnett Johnson Grove
Rogers Hornsby      NL, '15-33, 52-53, 58-59,62 AL '33-37,52 My War With Baseball,  1962 1962 Sisler Collins Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane / Dickey / Hartnett Alexander Johnson Grove Hubbell
Ed Bang Cleveland News sp.ed.  (1907-60) pp. 11, col. 2, Sporting News, Jan. 17, 1962 1968 Gehrig Lajoie / Collins McGraw Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Connie Mack Young Johnson Mathewson Alexander Plank Waddell
John Ogden NL pitch.('18,31-32),AL('28-29)NL scout pp. 23, col. 1, Sporting News, Nov. 16, 1963 1977 Terry Collins Traynor Wagner Ruth Mays Cobb Cochrane / Dickey Johnson Alexander Mathewson Walsh Grove Earnshaw
Mel Harder AL P, '28-47, Cle coach, '47-63,  NL c '64-69 pp. 25, col. 3, Sporting News, Mar. 14, 1964 2002 Gehrig Gehringer Dykes Cronin Simmons DiMaggio Williams Dickey / Cochrane Lyons Feller Grove Lopez
Tom Meany NYC sp. wr. ('23-56) 1964 1964 Gehrig Hornsby Traynor Wagner Ruth DiMaggio Cobb Dickey Alexander Johnson Mathewson Feller Grove Hubbell Stengel
Tommy Holmes Brooklyn sp. wr. (1926-56) 1964 1975 Gehrig Hornsby Traynor Wagner Ruth DiMaggio Cobb Dickey Alexander Johnson Mathewson Feller Grove Hubbell Stengel
Branch Rickey         AL pl'06-07,AL14-15,NL'19-64,exc.60-62 American Diamond, A Documentary of the Game, Branch Rickey, 1965) 1965 Sisler Collins Hornsby Wagner Ruth J.Jackson Cobb Cochrane Mathewson Johnson Nichols Waddell Young Alexander
E. A. Batchelor    AL only Detroit sp. wr.(1906-17) pp. 16, Sporting News, Aug. 28, 1965 1968 Gehrig Lajoie Weaver George Kell Ruth J. Jackson Cobb Cochrane Johnson Grove
Jimmy Dykes, 1920's team, AL only AL IF('18-39),AL'39-46,49-50,52-54NL55-58 autobiography, You Can't Steal First, 1966 1976 Gehrig Gehringer Joe Dugan Everett Scott Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane Grove Pennock
Jimmy Dykes, 1930 - 1941 team, ALonly AL IF('18-39),AL'39-46,49-50,52-54NL55-58 autobiography, You Can't Steal First, 1966 1976 Foxx  Gehringer Rolfe Appling T. Williams                      - Simmons Dickey Feller Grove
Jimmy Dykes, 1942 - 1967 team, ALonly AL IF('18-39),AL'39-46,49-50,52-54NL55-58 autobiography, You Can't Steal First, 1966 1976 Kuhl B. Richardson B. Robinson Rizzuto T. Williams DiMaggio Mantle Berra A. Reynolds W. Ford
Joe Reichler NYC sp. wr.('43-66) 1967 1989 Gehrig Hornsby B. Robinson Wagner Ruth Mays Cobb Dickey Johnson Mathewson Grove Koufax
Joe Falls Sp. wr.  NYC('51-52),  Detroit(53-03) pp. 2, col. 2, Sporting News, Jul. 5, 1969 2004 Gehrig Hornsby Traynor Wagner Ruth DiMaggio Cobb Dickey Johnson Grove Mack
Arthur Daly NYC spwr. (1926-74) NY Times, July 20, 1969 1974 Sisler Hornsby Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Dickey Mathewson
Al Schacht AL pitcher('19-20,21), AL coach('24-36) pp. 35, col. 5, Sporting News, Mar. 13, 1971 1984 Sisler Collins Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane Johnson Spahn
Stan Musial       NL only NL OF,1B  (1941-63) 1976 SA Terry Hornsby E. Mathews Wagner Aaron Mays Clemente Campanella Gibson Seaver Mathewson Alexander Hubbell Spahn Koufax E. Face C. Labine
Fred Lieb Sp. wr;Phil'10,NYC('11-34),St.Petersb.'34-80 1977 1980 Gehrig Collins Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane / Dickey Johnson Mathewson Grove Young Alexander Koufax Feller
George Kelly NL 1B (1915-32) *                        1984 1984 Sisler Frisch Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Ernie Lombardi Johnson Grove
Doc Cramer AL OF (1929-48) *                       1985 1990 Foxx / Gehrig Collins / Gehringer Bluege Appling Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane / Dickey Earnshaw Lyons Grove
Billy Rogell AL SS (1925,27-28,30-39,NL40) *                      1985 2003 Sisler Gehringer Traynor T. Jackson Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane Johnson Grove
Riggs Stephenson           AL IF ('21-25),   NL OF 26-34 *                     1985 1985 Gehrig Hornsby Traynor Sewell Ruth Speaker Cobb Hartnett Johnson Grove Vance
Whitey Witt AL OF ('16-26) *                   1985 1988 Sisler Lajoie Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker DiMaggio Dickey Johnson Grove
Frank Ellerbe AL 3B ('19-24) *                     1985 1988 Sisler Hornsby / Collins Joe Dugan Galloway Ruth / Jackson Speaker Cobb Severeid Johnson
Mary Koenig AL pl. ('25-31, NL('32-36) *                        1985 1993 Gehrig Hornsby Joe Dugan Appling Ruth Heilmann Cobb Cochrane Uhle Pennock
Willie Kamm       AL only AL 3B (1923-35) *                       1985 1988 Gehrig Gehringer Bluege Cronin Ruth Simmons Cobb Cochrane Earnshaw Grove
Jocko Conlon NL umpire (1941-64) *                       1985 1989 Gehrig / Terry Gehringer Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Hartnett Johnson Grove
Billy Wambsgnass,  A team AL 2B (1914-26) Player's Choice, McCaffrey, 1987 1985 Gehrig Collins Frank Baker Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Schalk Johnson Koufax Rollie Fingers
Billy Wambsgnass,   B team AL 2B (1914-26) Player's Choice, McCaffrey, 1987 1985 Troskey Hornsby L. Gardner Boudreau J. Jackson Wheat R. Oldring J. Archer Joe Wood Grove Willie Hernandez
Al Lopez NL catcher(1928,'30-46),AL Man('51-69) *                          1986 SA Terry Frisch / Hornsby Traynor Glen Wright Ruth Waner / Simmons Cobb Hartnett Dean Vance Hubbell Grove Pennock
Babe Herman NL OF (1926-37) *                            1987 1987 Gehrig Hornsby Traynor Travis Jackson Ruth T. Williams Cobb Hartnett Alexander Hubbell
Buck Leonard     A team Negro Leagues 1B (1933- Player's Choice, McCaffrey, 1987 1997 Gehrig Gehringer Traynor Cronin DiMaggio Speaker Cobb Cochrane Johnson Grove Joe Paige Stengel
Buck Leonard     B team Negro Leagues 1B (1933- Player's Choice, McCaffrey, 1987 1997 Terry Collins B. Robinson Pop Lloyd Ruth Mays Charleston Berra Newhouser Firpo Marberg
Billy Dickey AL catcher (1928-43,46), Yank coach ('49-57,60) *                 1987 1993 Gehrig Gehringer Traynor Cronin Ruth DiMaggio Simmons Berra Feller Grove Ruffing Gomez
Joe Sewell,     A team AL SS (1920-33),Yankee coach ('34-35) Player's Choice, McCaffrey, 1987 1990 Gehrig Gehringer Traynor Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Dickey Johnson Grove
Joe Sewell,     B team AL SS (1920-33) Player's Choice, McCaffrey, 1987 1990 Sisler Frisch G. Kell Cronin Mantle Mays DiMaggio Cochrane Ruffing Gomez
Luke Sewell AL catcher ('21-39,42), Browns Man. ('41-46, Reds Man. ('49-52) Player's Choice, McCaffrey, 1987 1987 Sisler Gehringer Bluege              --- Ruth Speaker Cobb                        --- Uhle Grove
Buck Jordan NL (1927, 29, '32-38) Player's Choice, McCaffrey, 1987 1993 Gehrig Hornsby Traynor Cronin Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane Johnson Hubbell
Buck Jordan NL (1927, 29, '32-38) Player's Choice, McCaffrey, 1987 1993 Terry Frisch Durocher Bluege Musial Mays DiMaggio Hartnett Dean Grove R: Gossage
Charlie Gehringer   A team AL 2B   (1924-42), Det. VP Player's Choice, McCaffrey, 1987 1993 Gehrig Hornsby Traynor Boudreau Ruth / Heilmann Speaker Cobb Cochrane Feller Grove Mack
Charlie Gehringer    B team AL 2B   (1924-42), Det. VP Player's Choice, McCaffrey, 1987 1993 Greenberg Collins J. Foxx Reese Ruth / Heilmann DiMaggio T. Williams Dickey Johnson Gomez
George Uhle AL pitcher (1919-33) Legends of BB, 1987 1985 Sisler Wambsganss Larry Gardner J. Sewell Ruth Speaker C. Jamieson L. Sewell / S. O'Neil Johnson Pennock
Steven Wulf spwr  ESPN Sports Illustrated, Oct.,1992 SA Gehrig J. Robinson Schmidt Ripken Ruth Mays Cobb Cochrane Mathewson Spahn Eckersly Stengel
John P. McCarthy, Jr. book author, 1994 book, Baseball's All Time Dream Team, 1994 SA Gehrig Lajoie Schmidt Wagner Ruth Mays Mantle Ewing Johnson Grove Clemens Alexander McCarthy
John P. McCarthy, Jr. book author, 1994 book, Baseball's All Time Dream Team, 1994 SA Foxx Collins Robinson Ripken DiMaggio Speaker Aaron Dickey Koufax Mathewson Waddell Young Paige Hubbell Carlton Ryan Stengel
Shirley Povich Wash spwr. (1922-74), kept writing afterwards pp. D1, D7,  Wash. Post, Jul. 7, 1997 1998 Gehrig Hornsby Schmidt Wagner Ruth T. Williams Cobb Cochrane Johnson Koufax
Pete Palmer,         A team spwr. & stastictician, Total Baseball Nov. 4, 1997 SA Gehrig Lajoie Schmidt Wagner Ruth Mays Williams Hartnett / Berra Johnson Young Alexander Mathewson Wilhelm Gossage Franco L. Smith McKechnie
Pete Palmer,         B team spwr. & stastictician, Total Baseball Nov. 4, 1997 SA Foxx Hornsby Mathews Dahlen Henderson Cobb Aaron Dickey / Cochrane Grove Nichols Clemens Clarkson Quisenberry Henke Tekulve Fingers Weaver
Bob Broeg St. Louis sp. wr. (46-85), cont. on P. Dis Jul. 19, 1998 SA Sisler Frisch Schmidt Wagner Musial Mays Cobb Bench Johnson B. Ruth B. Sutton Whitey Herzog
Donald Honig,      A team very prolific historical BB book writer Jun.23, 1999 SA Gehrig Hornsby Schmidt Wagner Ruth Cobb Williams Bench / Dickey Grove Koufax Mathewson Johnson
Donald Honig,      B team very prolific historical BB book writer Jun.23, 1999 SA McGuire Gehringer Traynor Rodriquez DiMaggio Mays Griffey Cochrane / Piazza Alexander Feller Seaver Spahn Mccarthy
Glenn Dickey,       A team spwr. San Francisco letter, June, 1999 SA Gehrig Hornsby Schmidt Wagner Ruth Mays Cobb Bench Johnson Grove Koufax Feller McGraw
Glenn Dickey,       B team spwr. San Francisco letter, June, 1999 SA Foxx Morgan(15) Traynor O. Smith Williams Aaron Musial Berra Mathewson Maddux Spahn Alexander Durocher
Furman Bisher Atlanta spwr. (1950-present) letter, Oct. 10, 1999 SA Gehrig Hornsby Traynor Wagner Ruth Mays Cobb Cochrane / Bench Johnson Koufax Young Spahn Grove Feller Gibson Ryun McGraw
Leonard Koppett    A team NYC spwr('48-73),Palo Alto,CA spwr(73-93) phone, Feb. 7, 2001 2003 Sisler Hornsby B. Robinson Wagner Ruth Mays Cobb Dickey Johnson Alexander Grove Koufax Feller Gibson Marichal Spahn McGraw
Leonard Koppett    B team NYC spwr('48-73),Palo Alto,CA spwr(73-93) phone, Feb. 7, 2001 2003 Gehrig Gehringer Schmidt O. Smith Aaron Speaker DiMaggio Gomez Ruffing Hubbell Maddux Mathewson Ryun B. Lemon D. Dean Stengel
Bill James prolific book author, popularizer new stats Hist. Abstract, 2001 SA Gehrig(14) Morgan(15) Schmidt(21) Wagner(2) Ruth(1) Mays(3) Cobb(5) Berra / Bench / Campy Johnson(8) Gibson(9) Paige(17) Grove(19) Alexander(20) Young(23) Spahn(36) Seaver(38) Mathewson(42)
Herman L. Masin    A team Senior Scholastic Magazine, ('36-03) phone, Dec. 22, 2002 SA Gehrig Hornsby Schmidt Wagner Ruth Speaker Cobb Cochrane / Bench Mathewson Johnson Alexander Koufax Grove Spahn Feller Seaver McGraw
Herman L. Masin    B team Senior Scholastic Magazine, ('36-03) phone, Dec. 22, 2002 SA Foxx Collins Traynor Rodriquez Williams Mays DiMaggio Dickey / Hartnett Dean Plank Marichal Gibson Carlton Martinez R. Johnson R. Clemens P. Richards
     *  = The "All-Stars" All-Star Baseball Book, by Nick Acocella & Donald Dewey, 1986
AL = team chosen only from AL;      NL = team chosen from only NL
Red High-Lighted = B or C Team SN = Sporting News ;   BBM = Baseball Magazine

All-Time All-Star Teams of Prominent Baseball Figures (spreadsheet) - spreadsheet has more team lists!

Email Bill Burgess

HomeGuru's Baseball Book StoreLink to UsBraintrust & Mailing ListsEmail the GuruContact InfoRead baseball analysis